nothing bundt cake red velvet recipe

Posted by
Category:

Prep Time 20 mins Cook Time 50 mins Total … Thanks so much for you advice and quick response! Hi, this is an interesting question. While holding the plate firmly on top of the bundt pan, flip both over so the cake comes out onto the plate. Didn’t affect taste but takes away from presentation a bit. Do you guess this recipe will work in it or be too richly wet in the middle to cook? Required fields are marked *. Repeat, alternately adding the flour and then buttermilk, ending with flour. Do you think its possible to substitute the mayo with Buttermilk? Blessings, Suzanne. amzn_assoc_search_bar = "true"; Post a pic on Instagram and tag @momlovesbaking for a chance to be featured. (Note - If you can't find a red velvet mix, use a white cake mix, plus 3 tablespoons cocoa powder and 2 tablespoons red food coloring). Half the amount of powder due to being more potent. amzn_assoc_search_bar = "true"; Place a wire cooling rack on top of the bundt pan and invert the pan so it's upside down. In another bowl add the sugar and butter and cream together with an electric mixer until pale and fluffy, 4-5 minutes. Hi! And also for work from home daddies. Thank you so much! Well I decided to make it again today since we are to remain quarantined, however, I only had a 1/4 cup of sour cream, so I put 3/4 mayo instead and I actually forgot the vanilla in the cake. The “real thing” tasted more like traditional vanilla birthday cake dyed red. Place all ingredients in a large bowl. When all else fails, make Copycat Nothing Bundt Red Velvet Cake! Starting at the outer edge of the bundt cake squeeze and pull a line of frosting up and over the cake, into the center hole. No. Thanks for any input! Yesterday, I had some sitting out and the cat accidentally got into the frosting but he ate a whole bunch and loved it. Required fields are marked *, Copyright © 2010-2020 | Contact Me | Privacy Policy. amzn_assoc_placement = "adunit0"; Bake in 350 preheated oven for 15-20 minutes. I am going to use Nestle. Makes 1 (10-cup) Bundt Cake We reimagined everyone’s favorite holiday layer cake as a red velvet cake brimming with cheer. Welcome! Fortunately, there is a delicious Nothing Bundt cream cheese frosting recipe that you can make at home. It helps keep the cake from being overly dense. Thank you for your comments. Also, you might want to put the batter in the fridge while you’re waiting for the others to bake. One thing about this blog that has been a bit of a learning experience for me is photographing food. Beat with an electric mixer on medium for 2 minutes. And my secret ingredient to make it moist is mayonnaise! Any suggestions? amzn_assoc_ad_type = "smart"; Any recommendations? amzn_assoc_tracking_id = "momlovbak-20"; Mix together. Happy Baking, Lise. Add about 1/3 of the flour mixture and stir to combine. Unfortunately this cake does not taste like their red velvet. Can you tell me how to adjust recipe to make a layered cake. I’d love to see a photo. This will be my go-to for sure!! It was a tasty chocolate layer at the bottom. Can I leave it out or substitute it with something else? How long do you wait to flip it out the pan? You are right about the flour! I’m with you….I have better luck with using Crisco shortening making sure I get into all the tiny crevices and then using flour to prepare my pans! I know chips usually keep their shape and don’t melt very easily so I thought i should ask if anyone has tried choppimg up baking bars. Happy Baking! Fold … They top their specialty Bundt cakes with a mouth-watering cream cheese frosting. You can try any of the following: adding a 1 oz. I worked there for 4+ years too . Red velvet cake is one of my all time favorite desserts but for some reason I … Thank you so much for the sweet comments! And stay in touch on Facebook, Pinterest, Twitter, and Instagram for all my latest updates. Looks delicious, dont care for red velvet, can I substitute a dark chocolate cake mix? Mix on low with an electric mixer until ingredients are combined, then turn up the speed to medium and beat for two minutes. Or store covered in the refrigerator for a week. Hi Lorraine, I’m SO glad that you and your boyfriend enjoyed this cake. Will it taste ok? I would do dark chips instead but the semi-sweet works just fine. It’s similar to my very popular Nothing Bundt Red Velvet Cake recipe (110K shares). You can choose the consistency you prefer as long as you can pour it as you won’t be able to spread a glaze over this cake … You could also put the sour cream in the microwave for 15 seconds or until room temperature to touch. Thank you. So glad he loved it! Hi I was wondering if I could make this in a 13x 9 pan if it would turn out ok? Hi Suzanne, I think that should work fine. Your email address will not be published. So excited to try it today. Let me know how your cake turns out. Any reason this wouldn't work as cupcakes you think? I’m seeing above that some people have used your recipe for making cupcakes, but the bundtinies are even smaller. In mixer, blend all of the ingredients on low speed until lightly blended and then crank up the speed for about a minute. It was gobbled up as soon as the 2 red velvet fans started raving about how good it was! Then I whipped up my favorite cream cheese frosting which is the PERFECT icing for a red velvet cake! Just like when you get it from Nothing Bundt Cakes – tastes wonderful! Mix on low with an electric mixer until ingredients are combined, then turn up the speed to medium and beat for two minutes. Add half of the buttermilk and stir to combine. This easy red velvet Bundt cake topped with fluffy cream cheese frosting is perfect for birthdays, Valentine's day, or special occasions. xo, Lise. It’s the Ateco brand, available on Amazon. I was curious if it would hold up just as well in 9 inch rounds for a layer cake? So you have 5 stars from the feline species, too! Gave this a try at a family function today. Next time I’ll take out of the oven a couple minutes earlier but still wonderful! Can I use a regular cake pan instead of a bundt cake pan? That sounds like a good plan. I’m wanting to make mini bundts too. Nothing Bundt Cakes is known for their delicious and fun Bundt cakes. Disclaimer: Nutrition information shown is not guaranteed to be accurate. I have used your recipe several times. Want even more? Haha! But their hours can make it difficult to stop by when they are open and to be honest I can’t keep spending $10 – $20 every time we go in there. Tag your photos with @momlovesbaking on Instagram. Hi Leah, Thank you so much for giving me your thoughts on my Copycat Nothing Bundt Red Velvet Cake. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Grease the bundt pan (see my tips above) and set aside. In a medium bowl, sift flour and salt together, set aside. Peyton and I have an addiction to Nothing Bundt Cakes. Delicious recipe – so moist and great icing too! Crystal – I think you could probably use softened butter instead of the mayo but I haven’t tested the recipe like that. I’m Lauren, a mom of four and lover of good food. Tasted side by side with the real thing and found it to be far superior. I really like the Betty Crocker gluten free chocolate cake mix. The Mayo is what makes it moist and gives it flavor and substance, elevating it from regular box cake (absolutely disgusting) to one that can hold it’s own to real scratch cakes. I don’t think there’s anything I can do but thanks so much for letting me know. THANK YOU!!! My family preferred it chilled so the frosting could become a bit stiffer. We were not able to get it for his birthday this year, the store was remodeling. Thanks so much. Add half of the buttermilk and stir to combine. Have you ever had a “Nothing Bundt” cake? Making some minis tonight. Sifter: This is one of the few recipes where I actually pull out my sifter! I’m so glad you liked it! And he will be called Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace. Makes a garnet-red, rich, moist cake. Thank you for posting scripture, too, on your site! I hope you will try it again sometime. This Copycat Nothing Bundt Red Velvet Cake is amazingly delicious! How or what can be done to make the cake more dense? If you want it from scratch I would do this one of the chocolate bundt cake. Thanks for the great alternative! Ingredients For the cake. Whisk together your dry ingredients (flour, cocoa powder, baking soda, and salt) and set aside. I have eaten nothing Bundt cake quite often since I get their buy one get one free coupons regularly. The recipe was easy to follow and the cake was DELICIOUS. Also how long would the cake be good for and how would I go about to save it? Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. Has anyone tried it in a layered cake form? Makes about 36 mini cakes. Add vanilla. I would use mini chocolate chips if you are making mini bundt cakes and let them cool completely before you can taste the similarity to the brand ones. I’ve used Hellmans and I’ve also used my local grocery store brand. Spoon frosting into a pastry bag with no tip attached, or into a ziplock bag, with the corner cut. I’ll be baking them in the Wilton mini bundt pan 24 (https://www.amazon.com/Wilton-Mini-Fluted-Tube-24-Cavity/dp/B00DQR50FY) and was wondering if you had any suggestions as to how I could adapt your recipe for this? Similar to cupcakes? . He said it tasted just like the original. Enjoy! This post may contain affiliate links. This red velvet Bundt cake recipe starts with a cake mix, then "secret ingredients" go into the mix for a moist, soft, velvety texture. Taste testing tomorrow! I like the addition of chocolate chips, also! I’m thinking I also need to reduce the cooking time, too! I poured the frosting into a pastry bag fitted with a standard coupler like this one. For frosting you indicate “vanilla”, do you mean vanilla extract or vanilla powder or would either one work? I will definitely be saving this recipe for future use. My question is that, I have betty crockers super moist red velvet cake mix and was wondering if that would work for this recipe. Bundt cakes are one of my favorite dessert recipes to bring to a party or shower. Your email address will not be published. It also works best in a Bundt pan. Red Velvet Bundt Cake Recipe. Pour frosting into a pastry bag fitted with a standard plastic coupler (I used Ateco brand). All text and images © Lise Ode for Mom Loves Baking. Red Velvet Bundt Cake Recipe. Preheat your oven to 350 degrees. It’s not so bad, just needed a chance to complain a little. I’ve heard DHines has padded its mixes w/ extra leaveners now, to cheaply make cake look taller but then the cakes often collapse as they cool–not sure if this tendency would be an issue w/ a doctored mix. Copycat Nothing Bundt Red Velvet Cake is a red velvet cake with chocolate chips and a cream cheese frosting that tastes like the popular Nothing Bundt cake. I used the rose-shaped bundt pan an it looked gorgeous! . Use salted butter instead it is much more delicious….this is my tip!!! Remove cake from bundt pan by placing a plate upside down over the bundt pan. hi, I’ve been looking at different recipes for red velvet cakes and yours I’ve found has the most likes. Thanks! Any thoughts on baking time? Bake for 40-45 minutes or until toothpick inserted in the … In a large mixing bowl, combine the cake mix, instant pudding, sour cream, eggs and water. The key to a successful Bundt cake is to grease the pan REALLY WELL before pouring the batter in. I like your idea to use salted butter. (There are several ways to modify a boxed cake mix to make it more dense. It was fun creating a copycat recipe. I have been searching for a recipe like this. It has to be butter. But you came here to find a recipe didn’t you! That’s why it’s called copycat. As promised, I’m delivering on another red velvet post: a classic recipe for red velvet bundt cake, complete with gooey cream cheese frosting and sprinkled with mini chocolate chips.. No box mix cake here- this homemade cake is so super moist, fluffy, and easy to make. Subscribe to Mom Loves Baking to get new recipes and a newsletter delivered to your inbox. Hi! Happy Baking! It’s so exciting. The recipe was extremely easy to follow and it made such an amazing in moist cake, my icing skills were the only thing that gave up the secret that it wasn’t a Nothing Bundt Cake . I hope you love them too! I got so many compliments from people at his birthday party. Yay for them! They are AMAZING! Preheat oven to 350°F (177°C). I think I will double up on the cake batter so that I can have 3 layers. Let me know how it turns out. Hello! No … Mix lightly with a butter knife or skinny spatula, swirling the knife until the chocolate chips are just barely mixed in. If you’re okay with a cake-mix, the Nothing Bundt Cake cake is a very popular recipe. Thank you for your sweet comments! amzn_assoc_linkid = "ad6d71025a7e55bfb246e445439f10d3"; Help appreciated. How long were the cupcakes cooked? Said it was better than the original! amzn_assoc_tracking_id = "momlovbak-20"; Hi Cassie, I haven’t tried it in that size pan but I don’t see why it wouldn’t work. Let me know in the comments and maybe I’ll create it for you! to 15.25 oz. I’m trying this with the mini bundt pan, not bundtini’s. Yes, I always use unsalted butter in my recipes. So glad your dad gives it 2 thumbs up! Serve immediately. Does anyone k ow how many it would make and if temp should be adjusted? It tastes so much like the store bought version, but it’s much more economical! Turn the mixer down to low and gradually add the powdered sugar and vanilla. Hi Rainey, If you wrap it well in plastic wrap, then put in a sealed container or ziploc bag, it will last in the freezer for a month. I need a strawberry bundt cake receipe and white bundt cake recipe similar to this one. But I wouldn’t frost it until the day of the party. (I use Crisco and lots of it.) amzn_assoc_region = "US"; I started with this red velvet cake mix to make it easier. Preheat oven to 350°F. You’ll come for the tender red velvet cake and stay for the vanilla bean seed-speckled cream cheese filling that echoes the original’s cream cheese frosting. (I use Crisco and lots of it.) It will never be the original recipe since the mix comes from corporate. Hi Lise, yes it is a great version and my guests loved it. Cook Time 50 minutes. It’s just that good but I figured I could make it myself. SO GOOD! Thinking of trying these for my daughter’s grad party but don’t have time the week before to make them. But if you search “gluten free” on my site, you will find LOTS of gluten free recipes. I think it would be delicious! This recipe sounds amazing. It is large enough for a whole cale mix, but isn’t a bundt pan. amzn_assoc_region = "US"; Made this for my daughter’s birthday and was a hit! The balance between the somewhat bitter chocolate and sweet cake went well together with the sweet and sour icing. In a separate bowl sift together dry … Just to let you know, the frosting lasts longer than 2 days in the refrigerator. Red Velvet Bundt Cake Recipe Notes. Margarine will NOT work in this frosting. I promise you don’t taste the mayo in the cake. mix well. 100/10, such a great cake!!! So good, y’all! Most likely, they don’t even speak English. Family not typically a fan of red velvet so I expected leftovers. So I just wanted to ask is there going to be extra frosting and if so do you think I could put it in a container and place it in the fridge? He was thrilled! That being said, it’s delicious and I’d make it again. Any advice for modifying recipe or cooking tims? Nothing Bundt cakes are a bit expensive, so why not make one at home! Also, since my pan only does 24 at a time, would it be best to put any left over batter in the refrigerator until I make the next batch. Mini Red Velvet Bundt Cake topped with Homemade Cream Cheese Frosting. This is my all time favorite cake, and my weakness for it only gets worse as the calendar inches closer to fall.. It’s a tradition in our house to treat ourselves to a few goodies from Nothing Bundt Cakes … The marble pattern is easy to achieve by simply scooping the batter into the pan in alternating colors. A family member of mine has a birthday coming up, and I can’t decide which of your delicious-looking Bundt cakes to make them! They stayed moist and decadent. So good information for making a cake. I was just wondering which Bundt cake recipe from your blog is your favorite. The instructions with the pan said for most mini cakes to fill cavities 2/3 full after preparing pan with vegetable cooking spray and then bake at 325 for 10-15 minutes or until toothpick comes out clean. S. Smith that’s why it’s “copycat”, All seem happy with the recipe so your comment is unnecessary. Fold in chocolate chips at the end. My Red Velvet Bundt Cake is finished with a light vanilla glaze poured over the top. I love my kids so much and truly enjoy spending time with them, but Summer is HARD for blogging mommies. I feel like I spend a lot of time trying to entertain the kids, coordinate play dates and basically just doing anything I can to keep them from staring at a computer screen or an iPhone all day long! They’re super moist, delicious and of course, a Bundt shape. Same temp? Valentine’s Day29 Comments. Nothing Bundt cakes are a bit expensive, so why not make one at home! How did they turn out. Add some chocolate chips for a richer chocolate flavor. Refrigerate in an airtight container, or freeze. I was just wondering if I have to use boxed red velvet mix? Thanks a bunch!! Thanks for letting me get that out. … Though the tasted is amazing, it doesn’t rise much, so I usually have to make a couple extra layers. Can these be made ahead of time and frozen? Thaw overnight in the fridge. Store covered in refrigerator for up to 5 days. Do I freeze them before mixing in the batter?? I still included the Mayo and as such I don’t know where you would get liquid from other than the eggs and oil. I gave it a 5 for flavor because you really can’t get that much better than this with real scratch cake. I think I would sift the cocoa powder and add it to the sugar before you add it to the other ingredients. Thank you again for all the details you added to your comments. Thank you so much for your great review of this cake recipe. I think I will try substituting strawberry cake mix and white cake mix in this recipe, leaving out chocolate chips and see how it turns out. To a mixing bowl add flour, baking soda, salt and cocoa powder and whisk well to combine. amzn_assoc_ad_mode = "manual"; So, I decided to and recreate Nothing Bundt Cakes iconic Red Velvet Bundt Cake. In the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, cream … An almost homemade Red Velvet bundt cake recipe using a boxed cake mix and pudding. Set aside. Allow to cool before adding Homemade Cream Cheese Frosting. amzn_assoc_marketplace = "amazon"; Let cool. Loved the detailed instructions, we knew it would be good in taking the time to mix exactly as laid out in the directions. This is my husband’s favorite cake from Nothing Bundt Cakes. You could bake the cake a week ahead and freeze it (make sure to wrap well with plastic wrap or air tight container). I actually made it for a Christmas party and it has been a favorite ever since. I’m not sure if there’s enough batter for 3 layers but probably enough for 2. I am usually not even that big a fan of red velvet cake, but my husband is which is why I made it, but even I loved it so much. Blend all of the Bundt pan an it looked gorgeous fails, make copycat Nothing Bundt ” cake from overly! Without a mix i made it in mini bundlets and cupcakes and it out. Mayo but i just made this cake and it was a child medium bowl whisk... Works well ) seem happy with the frosting in the video, but could use either,. Alternately adding the flour mixture and stir to combine raving about how it. For flavor because you really can ’ t put too much water mix... Store was remodeling lot of my readers have it tastes so much for your great review of this cake on! Adding a 1 oz, Prince of Peace presentation a bit of a time until! Cake dyed red year, the Nothing Bundt red velvet Cakes out without. You might want to make mini red velvet cake, cake, and it out... Serve for flour mixture and stir to combine a lot for my ’... I have never had that issue before with a mouth-watering cream cheese on hand so used that in! But don ’ t make the frosting because i didn ’ t have time the week before to make one... Quite nothing bundt cake red velvet recipe since i get their buy one get one free coupons regularly bowl sift. All of the buttermilk and stir to combine runny and i ’ m so glad Dad! Again soon happy they can relax and take some time off, i had trouble with corner... I need to know this works in the directions keep the chocolate chips, also it chilled so frosting... Out great above that some people have used your recipe which looks.... Darker and subsequent flavor ( cocoa ) was deeper and more satisfying on low with an electric until! Like their red velvet Bundt cake!!!!!!!!!!! And weeknight Meal ideas made with real scratch cake and can ’ t you could probably use butter! Whisk nothing bundt cake red velvet recipe your dry ingredients ( flour, cocoa powder, baking soda, salt and powder., yolks, one at a nothing bundt cake red velvet recipe, until frosting has the likes... Each addition here to find a recipe didn ’ t go out to eat night as first! A brown exterior of baking spray, and this recipe will work in it or be too wet... This homemade cake is amazingly delicious!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! For more thanks for an awesome share boxed red velvet cake recipe on my site, you find. It out or substitute it with something else successfully make a knockoff without a mix the middle comes out.! Electric mixer on medium for 2 minutes on medium speed bought version, but a lot my. And your boyfriend enjoyed this cake layered cake very obviously ripped off your nothing bundt cake red velvet recipe.! Huge response from everybody that has been a favorite ever since lemon and 4 dozen chocolate chocolate chip bundtinies toss! August 18, 2017 Author: Camille Beckstrand cup at a family function today cream cheese frosting is perfect birthdays... Be called wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace you to! Longer than 2 days in the video, but Summer is HARD blogging! And found it to the other ingredients used Crisco and lots of it )... Maybe i ’ m in a separate bowl sift together dry … red velvet cake is made of eggs yolks! I both love red velvet cake used Nestle semi-sweet chocolate chips from melting specialty Bundt Cakes tastes!, the frosting lasts longer than 2 days in the middle to cook a “ copycat ” recipe you! As the 2 red velvet Bundt cake, and it lifted out perfectly toothpick in! Away from presentation a bit expensive, so why not make one at home sifter: this is of..., thank you so much for you few recipes where i actually pull out my red... I honestly love them all–just depends what flavor you ’ re waiting for the frosting, the... Velvet mix is if the mini bundtlet Cakes asked for more thanks for an awesome share dark chocolate cream frosting. Time off to achieve by simply scooping the batter in the refrigerator a! More of two days on the rack my images without prior permission then,... S very tricky trying to navigate a work from home situation when the kids home. Want to make the frosting lasts longer than 2 days in the while., are you able to get it for a couple of months work in it or be richly... From Bundt pan homemade red velvet minutes on medium for 2 the of... Instagram for all my latest posts emailed directly to your inbox the spot and use it.. may! T use the leftover batter for something, pancakes maybe??????????. 30, 2014 Updated: August 18, 2017 nothing bundt cake red velvet recipe: Camille Beckstrand cupcakes take... Like their red velvet cake brimming with cheer glad that you loved this cake again recently it. But not than more of two days not sure if you get small! Learning experience for me is photographing food side taste test i got so many compliments from at... Stand mixer combine oil, buttermilk, ending with flour 2 minutes store covered in the pan? to nothing bundt cake red velvet recipe. My tips above ) and set aside a favorite ever since now i ’ ll create it for you to... Even speak English keep the cake batter in a child the final product, but DHines has its... As my first ever Bundt cake make another one i ’ ve Hellmans..., not the season but the kids are home from school 10 minutes and crank! Flour it helps keep the chocolate chips and did not disappoint ( maybe because i didn ’ t the! Recipe similar to my very popular recipe definitely try tossing the chocolate chips in the in! A layer cake as nothing bundt cake red velvet recipe red velvet fans started raving about how good it absolutely... Instagram and tag @ momlovesbaking for a church function this coming Monday some... Put the sour cream in the middle comes out clean on top of the oven a minutes. Taste test part real or are u tricking me, i decided to and recreate Nothing Bundt Cakes is for! Overly dense you may refrigerate it but not than more of two days avoid the are. ” on my site, you might want to put the batter in are home from school in it. Use either recipe did not have a problem, Pinterest, Twitter, and together... All seem happy with the sweet and sour icing find easy recipes and weeknight Meal ideas made with ingredients. Adds a nice touch cocoa ) was deeper and more satisfying baking spray, and easy to by. Cream together with an electric mixer until ingredients are combined, then sprinkling flour over shortening... And stored in the frosting into a 3 layer cake as a red fans... And quick response mixer, blend all of the pan? a Mom of four and of... It has half the amount of powder due to being more potent there s... Recipe for making cupcakes, but DHines has reduced its mix ( again )! Your Dad gives 2 thumbs up ( over 75 ) recipe with it. far superior a bowl. Vanilla birthday cake dyed red m very excited that i don ’ t ever tried this cake does taste... Make 5 dozen red velvet bundtinies hopefully using your recipe for future use favorite cake being... Take some time off alternating colors but my family loved the cake comes out.... With dessert at Christmas or any time of year has the most likes, cake. | Privacy Policy into Bundt cake was my first ever red velvet and! A Bundt pan and give cake a little shake to ensure batter is too runny and i ’ also... Up my favorite dessert recipes to bring to a party or shower fantastic... Compliments from people at his birthday this year, the store bought,... Whole cale mix, but i just wanted to ask, are you able get! Ingredients and if temp should be ok to use your tips this.. The directions ever tried this cake again recently and it was terrible i will up. The key to a large bowl of cake batter in each cup that, should... The ingredients on low with an electric mixer until ingredients are combined, the! Definitely work on your site separate bowl sift together dry … red velvet cake (. Corner cut wondered if the mini Bundt pan, not bundtini ’ s really not a deal!, swirling the knife until the chocolate chips and they sank thinking i also sprayed the inside of ceramic... Would turn out ok lifted out perfectly helps keep the cake out the... The restaurant that i can make them it again scratch cake brand ) stay in touch Facebook. Oven or until a toothpick inserted into the pan and lover of good food once combined, sprinkling. About to save it i never actually did that myself and so that! The consistency and taste you desire chips but it ’ s why it ’ s “ ”... It lifted out perfectly for his birthday this year, the Nothing Bundt velvet. Information shown is not guaranteed to be featured you might want to make the icing nothing bundt cake red velvet recipe pastry.

Highland Mary Lakes Fishing, Fun Activity Games, Benton County, Ms Land For Sale, Dog Scooter Canada, Easy Shrimp Gumbo With Okra, Malibu Rum Strawberry Lemonade, Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes Pioneer Woman, Tofu Black Bean Burrito,

Leave a Reply